INSTRUCTIONS TO TEAMS:  KEEP YOUR SUPERSTARS' PATH ON MEMORY LANE

This offseason, I kept rooting for the Yankees to retain Aaron Judge and sign him until his presumable retirement year, which his 9-year deal could conceivably do.  Of course, as everyone knows, he had just won the American League's MVP Award with all first-place votes!  He also broke the American League record with Homers at 62 - which some (including me) feel is the new record for ALL of baseball (for those who disqualify the obvious steroid-aided hitters).  In either case, another reason why I wanted Judge to be re-signed by the Yankees was because I love having our superstars, All-Stars or future Hall of Famers stay on the Yankees for their whole career.  If they're still producing to any respectable level, it's the right thing to do for both parties and the fans.

Many of us who rooted for the Yankees were spoiled from the late 90s team with the likes of Jorge Posada, Bernie Williams, and Hall of Famer Derek Jeter and, of course, our unanimously-voted Hall of Famer, Mariano Rivera.  Each of them were drafted by the Yankees and worked their way from our farm system to our team and, ultimately, through their retired days in baseball, wearing only the Yankees' pinstripes throughout each of those years.  Even someone who will never make the Hall of Fame but was a very good player, Brett Gardner, remained a Yankee throughout his career.  Most of us appreciated his grit and his contribution to our last championship team in 2009.

To demonstrate how rare it is to have one player remain on one team throughout their career, let's look at the Hall of Fame.  Based on recent conditions, only 54 players who were inducted into the Hall of Fame out of 234 played for only one team.  They include such greats as Chipper Jones; Edgar Martinez; Cal Ripken, Jr.; Ted Williams; Brooks Robinson; Sandy Koufax; Walter Johnson; Tony Gwynn; Jackie Robinson; Mike Schmidt; Al Kaline; Johnny Bench; Roberto Clemente; Craig Biggio; Bob Gibson; Stan Musial; Carl Yastrzemski; and some other Yankees including Lou Gehrig; Earle Combs; Bill Dickey; Phil Rizzuto; Mickey Mantle; Joe DiMaggio; and Whitey Ford.

Besides Judge, there are a few players from other teams who have played for only one team (so far) and are former All-Stars.  Some of them include Clayton Kershaw (Dodgers), Adam Wainwright (Cardinals), Joey Votto (Reds), Stephen Strasburg (Nationals), and Mike Trout (Angels).

I gave you a list of Yankees and even some players from other teams who remained in one uniform.  If you didn't notice, NONE of them were from the Mets!

While the pending re-signing of Judge was happening recently, our crosstown rivals, the NY Mets, had 2 players who were with them during their whole careers pending free agency:  Jacob deGrom and Brandon Nimmo.  Although I'm certainly not a Mets' fan, I was glad they re-signed one of their own, Brandon Nimmo.  Prior to that, I thought it was a disgrace for them to have not competed heavily for deGrom!  After all, he was clearly their best superstar over the past few years.  He also showed something I rarely see from the Mets, class!  Yes, he was a quiet type of guy, but he never showed up his competitors.  I've watched many Mets' games in my life and deGrom was certainly no Matt Harvey or Noah Syndergaard - thank God!!  Even during the period whereby Harvey & Syndergaard were demonstrating good numbers, "they" were the ones who got all of the hoopla from the Mets' organization, gaining nicknames and related promotions to their designated merchandise while deGrom stood in the shadows.  Yet, it was clear not too long thereafter that it was deGrom who was, by far, the best of the three!  

Recently, many from WFAN and the media began crucifying deGrom's injuries as a major factor and cited that it was becoming way too concerning.  They also claimed that deGrom did not want to stay with the Mets and that he was not in love with NY.  The latter may have been true, but why in hell should he have tried hard to stay with them?  After all, they kept ignoring him from the beginning, gave him inconsistent medical support, treated him as their third best starting pitcher for years, didn't sign him at the time he looked for a contract (prior to free agency), etc.  They, instead, saw nothing wrong with signing an almost-40-year-old pitcher (Verlander) from another team for 2 years in place of signing their own best starter, deGrom, to a 5-year deal, which would have ended with deGrom at a younger age than Verlander will be at the end of his contract.  Admittedly, Verlander just won a Cy Young, but deGrom was no slouch!  Plus, deGrom, as one of their own, deserved more than an outsider.  This man won his own Cy Young a few years ago without any run support from his team!  Thankfully, I heard 2 folks (Chris "Big Mac" McMonigle and Tommy Lugauer) from WFAN who voiced similar opinions to what I've been saying.  'm glad somebody in the media spoke up for deGrom.  Time will soon tell how healthy he will be for the Texas Rangers.

To further my point regarding the Mets' failures, in 1971, the NY Mets traded away Nolan Ryan.  Ironically, the pitcher with the most no-hitters (7) never threw one for his original team, the Mets.  In fact, until their supposed first no-hitter in 2012 by Johan Santana, they had none which meant that they played over 50 years without having their own - a MLB record for a team at that time.

{Of course, on a separate note, I must also mention that even that long-awaited no-hitter was questionable.  There was a controversial hit ball against Santana by none other than Carlos Beltran (a Cardinal at that time).  The ball happened to hit the chalk line which was not called a "hit", but should have, per baseball's rules.  Since it happened prior to the enacted allowance of replay usage, and since the umpires failed to examine the chalk line, the ball remained to being called a foul ball.}

Going back to my point of the Met's failures to retain players from beginning to end: in 1977, the NY Mets traded their "Franchise" player, Tom Seaver!  How on earth do you call him your Franchise, but you don't keep him within the Franchise?  Only the Mets do these extremely non-sensible things.  Tom Seaver (a part-time Met) and Mike Piazza (a part-time Met) remain as the only Mets to be inducted into the Hall of Fame with a Mets' designation.

Technically, a Mets' fan could point to David Wright.  It would be the only argument that could be had.  Their former Captain unfortunately had his career ended by a major back injury.  Don Mattingly had a similar back injury which ended his career, too.  We can only assume that they could have ended their careers in one uniform.  Worse than that was the instance of Thurman Munson, who tragically died in a plane crash a few years before his potential career-ending contract would have reached its ending term.

Besides that one "potential" case, I dare any Mets' fan to name any superstar player on their team that officially played their whole career in a Mets' uniform until retirement.  As I think even further (not something anyone ever wants me to do), I can name a few more of their drafted players who each showed greatness or at least very high skills, but they also left the Mets (or the Mets left them).  In fact, several of them ended up on the Yankees including Lee Mazzilli, Darryl Strawberry, and Doc Gooden.  Moreover, even one of their other very good pitchers from their 1969 championship team did not retire a Met - Jerry Koosman.  After all of these years, why haven't the Mets' fans made a fuss about this disservice of their end-of-service disgrace?

So, yes, I believe retaining some of the original drafted players is something each team should try to offer more effort towards.  Good job, Mets, for at least doing that for Nimmo; bad job for all of the other above average players you failed to keep.  Great job, Yankees, for retaining Judge and, by the way, for making him a Captain.  He clearly earned the opportunity to stay with us and to lead us!

Thanks.

THE JUDGE INSTRUCTED THE JURY & THEY AGREED!

Officially this week, the Yankees held a press conference announcing the re-signing of Aaron Judge!  The terms were:  9 years at a total of $360,000,000. They also did what most Yankees’ fans and team members wanted, they named him as their “Captain” – the 16^th
Captain in team history.  Derek Jeter was at the press conference which helped symbolize the reigning Captaincy hand-off.

The San Fransisco Giants and the San Diego Padres tried hard to persuade Judge to join their teams, but Judge and Hal Steinbrenner had strong discussions after Judge’s latest south coast offers.  Judge spoke to Hal during the wee hours of the morning and Hal convincingly offered Judge the final deal, keeping Judge in the only true pinstripes in baseball.  Supposedly, Judge was offered an additional $40 million by the Padres but it seemed like (this is my take) he instead told Hal to use it towards helping to improve the team in other areas.  If I’m correct, then that was truly an exemplification of Captaincy right there!  Also, kudos to Aaron Boone for reaching out to Judge hours before the ultimate conversation Judge had with Hal.  Apparently, Aaron went into an extreme heart-to-heart conversation about how much Judge meant to him and also to the teammates.  Judge did refer to that conversation when offering some of the reasons why he stayed with the Yankees.

Hal didn’t waste too much time demonstrating his promise to Judge as, days later, he signed MLB’s best starting pitcher (who was not about to be 40 years old) Carlos Rodón (who just turned 30 years old) to a $162,000,000/9-year contract.  His lefty arm and dominating arsenal is exactly what is needed in Yankee Stadium and, generally, most of the other ballparks too.

Since the beginning of the 2023 season is slightly over 3 months away, there’s still plenty of time for Hal and Cashman to improve our team even further than the re-signing of Judge, the new acquisition of Rodón, and a few other small deals they’ve recently done.  We all know our primary need is a new leftfielder, as no Yankee fan can take having Aaron Hicks anymore.  Perhaps Cashman can find some takers for him, Donaldson, and even IKF.  I would also like to see them add another bullpen pitcher, in addition to our recent re-signing of Tommy Kahnle.  I’m hoping whoever we potentially trade for in leftfield is no older than 30 years and is of All-Star caliber. We’ll see, but let’s not “Judge” our current roster too early!

THE FALL

Well, here we are again still licking our wounds over the failure to reach the World Series.  After defeating the Guardians 3 games to 2, we not only lost to the Astros, but we got swept.  Losing to them is overly tiresome already.  Boone, or whoever is making the decisions these days (e.g., Brian Cashman or the Yankees’ statisticians), made way too many blunders including:

- Putting in Lou Trivino (a so-so reliever) to try and get out of a bases loaded/nobody out situation that Gerrit Cole created.  (We were off the day before, so all of our premium relievers were available!)

- Constantly rearranging our lineup which even included having Anthony Rizzo in one game as a leadoff hitter and Gleyber Torres as a leadoff hitter in another game.

- Also, with the inconsistent lineup, we had some main players such as IKF not playing in several games.  I know he was struggling, but so were others who seemed to remain in the lineup (Donaldson).

Now, as usual, we are playing the waiting game to see which free agents we are retaining and which ones we’ll try to sign.  Of course, that topic begins with Aaron Judge (the American League’s soon-to-be MVP).  Most of the baseball writers have reported that the San Fransisco Giants are publicly committing towards doing whatever it takes to sign Judge who is from their hometown area.  On the flip side, Hal Steinbrenner was interviewed and made it very clear that Judge belongs in the Yankees’ pinstripes.  He even answered a question positively regarding the chance of making Judge a Captain of the team.  Additionally, he admitted that he has been in one-on-one meetings with Judge – something Hal’s father used to tactically do.  At this point in time, I feel rather confident that Judge will remain a Yankee for many years to come.  My opinion is based on Hal’s comments and also the fact that the Yankees just signed our other top free agent, Anthony Rizzo to a 3-year deal (the 3rd year has a team option).  The Rizzo signing is very significant because he and Judge are very good friends and so, supposedly, are their wives.

WHAT A SEASON!!

JUDGE

Judge broke the American League's homerun record with 62 homeruns this season - one more than Roger Maris!  I, along with most baseball purists, consider it the most of all time, disconnecting those who were found to be cheaters:  Bonds, McGuire, and Sosa.  It got very strainful during his final 2 weeks, but he never changed his at-bat approach.  He almost won the triple crown, but came up slightly short with his overly impressive .311 batting average (the leader ended up being Luis Arráez from the Minnesota Twins).  Still, he easily won in homeruns, and led the Major Leagues with 131 RBIs, .686 Slugging Percentage, .425 On-Base Percentage, and 133 Runs Scored.  He also stole 16 bases out of 19 attempts and was a defensive machine with a perfect percentage in fielding, playing both CF and RF.  Also, defensively, no one dared to run on him, unless they were ignorant idiots.  He was clearly the MVP in the sense of stats and in the sense of actuality.  The Yankees would not have made the playoffs without him - no doubt!

The Yankees failed to sign him over the winter and right before the season started this year.  We all wanted them to sign him, but their GM and ownership failed to do so.  Based on his excellent season (one of the greatest of all time), the Yankees will now have to offer a heck of a lot more money than they would have back in April!  Hopefully, they wallop him enough to keep him away from other teams, including the Mets.  I suggest making him a Captain which they can tie to some extra payout - something other teams can't legitimately separate as an offer.

THE SEASON

The Yankees looked almost unstoppable until August arrived.  Then, they looked like a team with no hitting abilities whatsoever.  I immediately think of the word, "agita" in relation to how I felt during that stressful period.  The good news is that they turned it around during the last month, or so.  Promoting Oswaldo Cabrera certainly helped more than I thought it would - he wasn't even one of their top 3 prospects.  Then, the return of Rizzo and Stanton helped bring our team back to the team we were supposed to have all along.

THE PLAYOFFS

We now go into the playoffs tonight for the ALDS to face one of the winners of the Wildcard, the Cleveland Guardians.  Gerrit Cole starts our first game tonight.  Let's keep our fingers crossed while still trying to clap when needed.  Gerrit has been anything but an ace, especially for us in games like this, such as our Wildcard loss last year.  Hopefully, he pitches well enough to give us this game with Nasty Nestor waiting in the wings.

 STATISTICS FOR HITTERS & PITCHERS

As you all know by now, we are living in an era of overloaded statistics (sabermetrics) in baseball!  Some of the stats are certainly interesting, but way too many of them are ridiculous.  I really hate it when we are trying to watch a game on TV and the announcer(s) begin throwing out one stat after another.  Many times, we have to have grids on our screen on top of the live image of the game.  Over 20 years ago, most of us sought out much simpler stats.  For a hitter, we initially looked immediately at their batting average, homeruns, and RBIs and, secondarily began looking at SLG (Slugging Percentage) and O.P.S. (On-Base plus Slugging Percentage).  For a pitcher, we usually looked at their Wins/Losses, E.R.A. (Earned Run Average), strikeouts, and walks.  Baseball cards still offer such stats with some extra categories, but thankfully haven’t gotten ridiculous {yet}.  Besides, a card would never be able to fit all of the stats currently bandied unless it was done on with the tiniest font!

In some of my past articles, I have mentioned a pitcher’s W.H.I.P (Walks & Hits per Inning Pitched) and in my previous article earlier this week, I introduced W.P.A. (Win Probability Added) for the first time in my writings.  Now, it’s time to emphasize why I think both identify a lot to any baseball fan:

Let’s begin with the pitcher’s W.H.I.P.  As most of you know, pitchers of this generation fall into 3 main categories:  starter, middle reliever, and closer.  A stat such as E.R.A. is not a one-size-fits-all piece of information.  Many relievers (especially closers) come into a game and have to deal with runners already on base.  If the middle relievers or closers do in fact give up some such runs, the inherited runners are not charged against their own personal E.R.A.s.  Hence, an average  middle reliever or closer has a major advantage of sustaining a low E.R.A. which can be deceiving.  A starting pitcher’s wins and losses can sometimes be very misleading.  Ask Jacob deGrom who hasn't gotten a win as often as he should have (only 77 wins with 53 losses) due to a weak bullpen during most of his pitching years as a Met; yet he still achieved a W.H.I.P stat of 1.01.  That scenario helps demonstrate that W.H.I.P. offers a more accurate evaluation of a pitcher.  Whether they’re a starter, middle reliever, or closer, they each individually control the amount of their own personal walks and hits, so no real outside factors distort their W.H.I.P stats.  It's ironic to me, by the way, that W.H.I.P. is becoming more commonly today because I actually used to analyze pitchers by looking at their Walks and Hits per innings pitched (along with their E.R.A.) well over 25 years ago!

As far as hitting stats are concerned, I’m not going to tell you that homeruns, R.B.I.s, batting averages, SLG, and O.P.S. don’t matter because they do!  My reasoning for also loving W.P.A. (Win Probability Added) is that it "collectively" offers a quick glimpse of “one” stat instead of multiple stats; plus, it has more centralized focus of what the hitter truly fails at or succeeds at when the games matter the most, again without outside distortions.  If a hitter has played in the Majors for at least 4 seasons, it's a very useful and defining barometer tool to use.  One of the negatives of it beyond that need is that it's not commonly used by baseball journalists nor is it quickly accessible when reviewing players' stats.  It's, instead, usually buried near the advanced batting stats.

Judging a player's value when the game really matters is a great evaluation of any offensive player.  For instance, last week Joey Gallo hit a two-run homerun when the Yankees led the game in the ninth inning by 7 runs.  That's a demonstration of how misleading it can be if someone was just examining homeruns.  Plenty of players also drive in runs when the game is a slaughter, but often fail when you need a 2-out hit or sacrifice fly.  Yankees’ fans know all about clutch hitters, especially in the playoffs/World Series with Reggie Jackson (Mr. October) and Derek Jeter (Mr. November). 

Neither the W.H.I.P. nor the W.P.A. are perfect stats, but they are usually great single-point indicators of a player. To best use these 2 stats, in my opinion a W.H.I. P. below 1.2 is typically a very good pitcher while one who pitches below the 1.02 calculation is phenomenal!  For the W.P.A. stat, my opinion is that any hitter who achieves a 2.00 often in a season or any hitter with a total number above 5.00 is a very good hitter.  If a player’s stat exceeds a total of 20.00, then he's excellent (and I want him on my team immediately as long as he's under 35 years old)!  Current Yankees who exceed the 20.00 are Anthony Rizzo and Giancarlo Stanton.

To demonstrate my points of these two stats further, here are the Top 25 Leaders of each:

W.P.A. Leaders (as of 7/22/22)

01) Albert Pujols (69.95)

02) Miguel Cabrera (59.04)

03) Joey Votto (51.63)

04) Mike Trout (47.41)

05) Paul Goldschmidt (41.92)

06) Freddie Freeman (36.54)

07) Bryce Harper (33.89)

08) Anthony Rizzo (31.67)

09) Andrew McCutchen (31.18)

10) Giancarlo Stanton (28.14)

11) Nelson Cruz (25.13)

12) Josh Donaldson (24.83)

13) Christian Yelich (24.01)

14) Mookie Betts (23.21)

15) Nolan Arenado (22.63)

16) Matt Carpenter (21.09)

17) Robinson Canó (19.81)

18) Starling Marte (18.58)

19) Justin Turner (18.07)

20) Justin Upton (17.85)

21) José Abreu (16.64)

22) Michael Brantley (16.62)

23) Kris Bryant (16.22)

24) Carlos Santana (15.73)

25) Charlie Blackmon (15.54)

26) Aaron Judge (14.75)

27) Jose Ramirez (14.26)

28) Eric Hosmer (14.22)

29) Juan Soto (14.15)

30) J.D. Martinez (14.09)

(By the way, Babe Ruth’s W.P.A. was 111.41!!!)

W.H.I.P. Leaders (as of 7/22/22)

01) Shane McClanahan (0.80)

02) Tony Gonsolin (0.84)

03) Justin Verlander (0.88)

04) Corbin Burnes (0.90)

05) Sandy Alcantara (0.90)

06) Aaron Nola (0.91)

07) Miles Mikolas (0.96)

08) Alek Manoah (0.96)

09) Joe Musgrove (0.97)

10) Triston McKenzie (0.98)

11) Gerrit Cole (0.98)

12) Yu Darvish (0.99)

13) Nestor Cortes (1.00)

14) Tyler Anderson (1.02)

15) Julio Urias (1.02)

16) Jordan Montgomery (1.05)

17) Luis Garcia (1.06)

18) Max Fried (1.06)

19) Zac Gallen (1.08)

20) Frankie Montas (1.08)

21) Zack Wheeler (1.08)

22) Pablo Lopez (1.09)

23) Robbie Ray (1.09)

24) Cole Irvin (1.10)

25) Logan Webb (1.10)

 

(By the way, Mariano Rivera had exactly a 1.00 W.H.I.P.)

MIDWAY EVALUATION OF THE NY YANKEES

The Yankees have produced a remarkable year!  It’s the All-Star Break, which is always a good time to evaluate our team.  Here’s my assessment of their performance as they are currently one game beyond the half-way point of the season:

Record

The Yankees currently have the best record in baseball with 64 wins and 28 losses (a .696 winning percentage).  That percentage after 82 games is the third best since the 2001 Mariners (66-26) and 1998 Yankees (68-24).  Their standings hold them 13 games above the second-place Rays, 14.5 over the Blue Jays, 16.5 over the obnoxious Red Sox, and 18 over the Orioles.  Their 28 come-from-behind wins has caused us fans agita, but what the hell – it leads the Majors and always offers us hope!

Pitching

Their pitching staff is the third best in the Majors with a 3.08 E.R.A. (Earned Run Average).  The opposing offense has a meager .214 batting average against us.  We also go into the break with a phenomenal W.H.I.P. (Walks and Hits per Innings Pitched) of 1.08! 

This year’s key starting pitchers include Gerrit Cole.  His record is at 9 wins/2 losses, a 3.02 E.R.A., and a 0.98 W.H.I.P.  {Nasty} Nestor Cortes has 7 wins/3 losses, a 2.63 E.R.A., and a 1.00 W.H.I.P.  The rest of the starting pitchers’ W.H.I.P. is as follows:  Luis Severino (1.07), Jameson Taillon (1.13), and Jordan Montgomery (1.04).  To top all of that, they have J.P. Sears who they’ve called up to spot start and provide some bullpen help.  He seems to have a lot of potential and has proven it so far in his short stint with a 0.95 W.H.I.P.  Having these starters and having someone with talent like Sears makes our starting pitching staff strong.  If the need for Cortes (who is pitching more innings than he has in the past) to lessen his pitches comes along, Sears should be good for that role.  Of course, you can never have enough pitching; so, an acquisition of another great starter would still be welcome - offering us even more flexibility and strength.

In the bullpen, they have two superstars in Clay Holmes and Michael King.  Holmes has 16 saves after being the main closer during Aroldis Chapman’s injury absence.  Chapman had 9 saves earlier in the season and has recently returned but lost his closer role to Holmes.  All of baseball has taken notice of Holmes and his dominating 0.87 W.H.I.P., 1.31 E.R.A., and other successful numbers.  Mainly as a middle reliever, Michael King has also dominated hitters with his W.H.I.P. of 0.95 and 2.19 E.R.A.  In all, the relievers have been well above most teams and offer confidence to us fans.

Hitting

The Yankees have a lot to brag about so far this season including their offense.  It all begins with Aaron Judge.  He has been having an awesome year.  It seems like every broadcast offers a stat comparing him to Mickey Mantle, Roger Maris, Babe Ruth, and many of the other all-time greats!  Currently, he has smashed 33 homeruns and has an O.P.S. (On-Base Plus Slugging) of .982.  His homerun total is projected to be at least 60 if all goes the same for the rest of the season, which is why Maris is usually mentioned.  

Giancarlo Stanton has also been having a heck of a year so far with 24 homeruns, 61 R.B.I.s, and an .835 O.P.S.  His power has N.A.S.A. considering him to hit their rockets to the moon to save on their gas spend - LOL!  

Other hitters have also contributed including Gleyber Torres who is also having a decent year especially compared to last year.  Then, there’s Matt Carpenter.  He has only been a NY Yankee since the last week in May and, in only 79 at-bats, has produced 13 homeruns, which is an average of 1 homerun for every 6 at-bats!  He has also driven in 34 runs in 31 games!  His current 1.380 O.P.S. is even higher than Judge and almost anyone who has ever played the sport!  Defensively, the man has defended at many varying positions without a gripe and rather effectively.  Such wonderment from him is not expected to carry on throughout the whole season, but all fans have been enjoying the ride enormously!  

Does anyone miss Gary Sanchez?  Our catching offense has been much improved with the recent addition of Jose Treviño (and the defense from him and Higashioka has skyrocketed this season) compared to the Gary Sanchez era.  Treviño has done so well that his Win Probability Added ranks him ahead of the Mets’ Pete Alonso.  

Let's add a very good or an excellent outfielder to our team to stop our bleeding eyes every time we look at Joey Gallo strikeout as he has unfortunately shown that NY is too much for him.  Some critics believe we don't need to add another bat, but anyone who stands still should expect to be passed.  Improvements should be an ongoing thing, especially for "our" Yankees!

Season-Ending Outcome:

It’s easy math to project that the Yankees will win at least 100 games!  That’s a comfortable thought.  Our problem for quite a while is actually getting to the World Series, something we have to do before we can win another one!  The good news this season in regard to that is unless we completely fall apart, we should get the homefield advantage over all teams.  A slight concern would be the Astros, as they are not too far behind us at this moment in time.  To help our cause, as mentioned above, we have is to improve our team.  The infamous trade deadline is weeks away (August 2).  Come on Cashman, you need to be more aggressive this year than you’ve been in recent years.  Let's not just improve slightly, let's topple it ridiculously!  We all want it, and 2009 is fading too far away in our rearview mirror.

GARY SANCHEZ TRADED - MORE ABOUT SUBTRACTION THAN ADDITION

Many Yankees' fans were elated to have learned about last night's trade of Gary Sanchez.  That trade with the Minnesota Twins consisted of Gary and Gio Urshela (our third baseman who was supposed to become our shortstop) packaged to the Twins for Josh Donaldson (3B), Isiah Kiner-Falefa (SS), and Ben Rortvedt (C).

What the fans were not happy about was the fact that it was Donaldson who called out Gerrit Cole last June for using an illegal substance on the baseball.  Various pitchers interviewed about the substance (known as Spider Tack) did not deny it.  Cole uncomfortably danced around the whole issue during a very awkward interview.  A lot of pitchers suddenly began losing their spin rate (including Cole) after the action of inspection of the pitchers was enacted by MLB.  In my opinion, if the batters can use pine tar (George Brett!) and gloves to grip the bat better, then the pitchers should also be able to use something to grip the ball better - as long as the baseball scientists can prove it does not act the same as spit or Vaseline - many baseball players actually support it including some hitters!  They state that it's better that the pitcher has control of where the ball is going as opposed to potentially getting hit with a 99-mph fastball.

Donaldson has always been a fiery ball player.  If he was on our team and accused an opposing pitcher of cheating, most NYY fans would join him with his take, and they would chant some "unfriendly" words towards the pitcher whenever given the chance.  While most are reacting immediately to the attainment of Donaldson affecting Cole, they should also remember Cole's dislike for Sanchez being his catcher!  When the two of them were battery mates, Sanchez would often act like he was daydreaming and not catch Cole's pitches - even some without movement!  Although it was never officially disclaimed by Cole, it was evident by his reactions and by the reaction of Boone that Higgy (Kyle Higashioka) was the preferred catcher.  Each of the recent games that Cole pitched, he was typically matched with Higgy as his battery mate.  Sanchez was demonstrating those catching lapses way too often over the past few years.  His hitting was also becoming a hindrance to the lineup.  I hope he improves in a more relaxed environment in Minnesota, but as a departing NY Yankee, I will simply offer, "Good riddance."