GREATEST CLOSER/GREATEST PITCHER

Today, the Yankees dedicated a plaque to Mariano Rivera, which will be officially placed into Yankee Stadium’s Monument Park tomorrow.  As he has been my favorite Yankee in the last 35-plus years (the person that inspired me to write my first blog), I wanted to share some of my loving thoughts about not just a great Yankees, but (from everything seen and heard) one of the greatest people that has been put on this earth:

There aren’t many players in Major League Baseball who can be unquestionably deemed as the best overall player at that position.  For instance, Derek Jeter was one of the greatest shortstops of all time, but not unequivocally the greatest.  I would certainly argue that he’s the shortstop you want in any playoff game, though!  Some may say that Willie Mays was the greatest centerfielder, but others would have legitimate arguments supporting Mickey Mantle, Joe DiMaggio, Duke Snider, Rickey Henderson, or (in recent times) Ken Griffey, Jr.  In my opinion, there are only 5 positions/roles that have very little room for disputing who the greatest overall performer was:

1st Baseman - Lou Gehrig
3rd Baseman - Mike Schmidt
Left Fielder - Ted Williams
Right Fielder - Babe Ruth
Closer - Mariano Rivera

I’ve felt, for many years, that Mariano was the best closer (even after loving the “Goose” back in the late 70s and early 80s).  While most Yankees’ fans loved Mariano, I kept underscoring his greatness beyond what he had been doing for the Yankees singularly.  I emphasized Mariano’s extreme greatness to many fans and non-fans over 10 years ago because it’s rare (very rare) that we get to witness the best of any role in baseball.  So, while it was happening in each of our lives, I wanted all baseball fans who I personally knew to realize Mariano’s extraordinariness, not just taking him for granted as he continued gaining save after save to his collective stats.

Based on the short list above, most of us were fortunate enough to see Mariano and some of us were additionally lucky to have also seen Mike Schmidt and possibly even Ted Williams.  I’ve spoken to many baseball fans about Mariano and the vast majority agree that he was the best closer of all time.  That opinion is even shared by the typically biased non-Yankees’ fans of the Red Sox and Mets!  

As time has passed, since Mariano’s retirement from baseball back in 2013, I’ve begun to think even further about Mariano’s dominance on the mound.  With that, I began analyzing who the most dominating pitchers of all time might be.  Fans would definitely have a dispute over that choice!  Some would select Cy Young, Walter Johnson, Sandy Koufax, Bob Gibson, Bob Feller, Lefty Gomez, Whitey Ford, Tom Seaver, Greg Maddux, and even more in that argument.  I don’t even know which pitcher I would choose!  In my thought process (something that’s extreme) I began realizing that the greatest “pitcher” (not necessarily “starting pitcher) on the mound (again, in my opinion) was Mariano!

Of course, I realize that starting pitchers and closers are like comparing apples and oranges; but, segregating it to simply envisioning a pitcher on the mound facing the greatest hitters, Mariano’s numbers would certainly support him as the choice.  To bring this analysis to an outmost and ridiculous scenario (I told you my thought process was extreme), supposing one’s life was on the line and they had to choose one pitcher that could throw the ball past an enemy who happened to be the greatest hitter of all time (perhaps an evil Babe Ruth).  Would you choose one of the greatest starting pitchers or would you choose the undisputed greatest closer to get that hitter out?  I know who my choice would definitively be!